IGN hates Nintendo

PieGuy02

That one Random guy with everything unfitting.
Credits
4,400
Well,since Audrey Drake (the last and only one who really liked Nintendo at IGN) left,the last 2 have really been giving the Nintendo games a rough time.Animal Crossing New Leaf got a 9.6/10 because Audrey.But the last 2 have done this:

Game and Wario : 5.1

NSLU : 7.3

Mario and Luigi:Dream Team : 8 (BULLSHIT cause the others got great reception and this was just as good)

The IGN Nintendo Team is fallng apart,while the other 2 have tons of people already.Plus,the last 2 really like the mature content a lot better,especially sony.The only Nintendo stuff they like is the Smash bros games,modern zelda,and mario (which is a lie).Hopefully Pikmin 3 gets a very good score,though i doubt it'll get more than a 9.

Maybe they can hire more people,like the guy from GameXplain.But till we get someone who is just as awesome as Audrey,we'll be seeing a lot bad scores :(.
 
Game and Wario was truly a bad game, it's lucky enough it even got a 5.

New Super Luigi U is just a quick rehash.

Dream Team's score seems perfectly reasonable.

The only thing they hate is Sonic.

Otherwise i don't see the problem.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Game and Wario was truly a bad game, it's lucky enough it even got a 5.

New Super Luigi U is just a quick rehash.

Dream Team's score seems perfectly reasonable.


The only thing they hate is Sonic.


Otherwise i don't see the problem.



I agree with you man, I see no problem with their reviews on nintendo games. Only chosen few nintendo games are worthy of a 8.5 or higher.
 
Game and Wario was truly a bad game, it's lucky enough it even got a 5.

New Super Luigi U is just a quick rehash.

Dream Team's score seems perfectly reasonable.

The only thing they hate is Sonic.

Otherwise i don't see the problem.


*MY FEELS*Well,I'll respect what you think (G.A.W was crappy though lol)but my point was that IGN will most likely start giving future Nintendo games bad scores since (like i stated) the last 2 people on the Nintendo Team don't really care much for Nintendo.The only good thing is that Audrey left to join the Nintendo Treehouse as a Localization Writer http://www.ign.com/blogs/aminka/2013/06/19/aminka-says-goodbye/.So hopefully we see her name in some credits somewhere.
 
Just because you say they don't care for nintendo much doesn't mean they are going to give all future releases a bad review. They are journalist gamers. It's part of their job to be harsh game critics. I think Pokemon X and Y will do fine along with whatever other games Nintendo will release this year. Besides the majority of IGN readers always disagree with most of their reviews. I usually dislike everything they post.
 
This is why you don't listen to reviews. I've said this before, but it's all a matter opinion. People love Wind Waker and I think it's a terrible game. Doesn't mean that I'm right or the people who love Wind Waker is right. Reviews mean nothing when buying a game. You have to go out there and try the game for yourself or you'll never know if you really like it or not.
 
The Game & Wario and New Super Luigi U scores seem pretty reasonable to be honest. The latter because while it's technically a new game, it's more like a Lost Levels for New Super Mario Bros U than something that truly moves the series on, and it doesn't take advantage of some things that DLC should take advantage of (like actual new resources in the graphics, music, enemies, bosses, world maps, etc areas).

As for Dream Team... while I'd say it's a slightly harsh score, I can sort of see why they gave it that. I mean, the game does start slowly... and from what I can tell, reviewers don't seem to put a lot of effort into playing video games in general, so it's possible they either couldn't finish the game in the time before the review was due and hence didn't experience the best bits or... something else. Bit like the situation with the Legend of Zelda Twilight Princess' opening.
 
I thought I'd have a look at other reviews by IGN, Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare -the last game in that series I bothered to play xD- got a review score of 9.4 though I found the only good thing about the game was the graphics o.o From the sounds of it, IGN choose graphics over gameplay (I may be completely wrong, I rarely look at reviews so I am just making judgements). Alternatively, the reviews could be biased as some people want basic action games whilst others prefer a good puzzle and these reviews may be done by people who hunger for action... If you are going to buy games based on reviews, at least look at an array of reviews to find what the averages are ^^
 
To me, giving dream team a 9 may be giving it a little too much credit, though i'm still getting it. Gotta own all 4 of the Mario and Luigi games, you know.
 
An 8 is hardly a bad review, and they do make valid points during the course of it. In any case, a sample size of three is way to small to claim IGN is biased. I DO think they need a bigger and broader viewed Nintendo team though. Nintendo Life and My Nintendo News (Which I don't like as well as the first because their comments and community are horrendous) update multiple times a day with all sorts of interesting Nintendo News, comments, discussions and quotes from designers and such. IGN posts the same for Playstation and Microsoft, but rarely if ever for Nintendo.
 
Just because you say they don't care for nintendo much doesn't mean they are going to give all future releases a bad review. They are journalist gamers. It's part of their job to be harsh game critics. I think Pokemon X and Y will do fine along with whatever other games Nintendo will release this year. Besides the majority of IGN readers always disagree with most of their reviews. I usually dislike everything they post.


Most likely. ^_^ Probably also 3rd party games too but lets just see.And like I said,THEY NEED TO HIRE THE GUY FROM GAMEXPLAIN!The Nintendo team is really IGNorant!
 
Back
Top