Self-defense or not?

Lleyn

Beep
Full GL Member
Credits
1,500
This week in Beijing, the trial began for a 45-year-old man accused of killing a man with a samurai sword after he picked a fight with the man’s 23-year-old son. The incident occurred on October 19 last year and started over an argument on the bus.
 
The father and son from Hebei Province were staying in Beijing as migrant workers. According to the son, he was riding on the bus when the person sitting behind him began kicking the back of his chair. He complained and the argument escalated. He says the man and his friends began hitting and kicking him, until they were separated by the driver and other passengers.
 
The son then phoned his father, asking him to wait at the bus stop. He said, “I was afraid they would follow me off the bus and start something again, so I wanted my father and some others to meet me at my stop.”
 
The father went to the bus stop, bringing a samurai sword along with him. When his son alighted, the other men from the bus did as well, surrounding the pair.
 
According to the father, he didn’t intend to use the sword, but since he’d heard there were a lot of men in this group, he thought he could use it to scare them off. He scolded the men, saying “What do you go around hitting people for?”
 
One of the men responded, “Because we want to,” and punched the father in the stomach. Then there was a scuffle, during which several of the men produced knives and the son grabbed a discarded stick. During the melee, the father struck one of the men with the sword, who later died from his injuries.
 
According to his deposition, the father brought the sword but it never occurred to him that the men might try to rush him. However, witnesses reported seeing the father stab the man with intend. In the courtroom, the parents of the deceased asked why he hadn’t tried to stop the fight, rather than participating. He responded, “I made a mistake. I was upset because they had hit my son.”

So do you think the father was right in what he did?
 
Justified. I would've done the same thing but I would've used a gun since I'm not familiar with using swords. But since China loves being China, of course the defender gets punished. I hate the PRC government, the people should just overthrow the damned regime.
 
No, it's not the government's fault, it's the Chinese society's... changing
the government cannot change how people view or do things in a country. No matter the government, people in power will always have the last word or say in anything, anyways. & these things can also happen in America or Canada. You're
just biased against PRC.
 
Sanaki said:
No, it's not the government's fault, it's the Chinese society's... changingthe government cannot change how people view or do things in a country. No matter the government, people in power will always have the last word or say in anything, anyways. & these things can also happan in America or Canada. You're
just biased against PRC.
Atleast in America they give you a chance to prove that you or a loved one was in danger, in China your summarily executed and soon afterwards a billboard with your name underlined in red is displayed as an example to the rest of the cattle. And I don't give 2 shits about whether it won't change the mindset of some people, that doesn't justify the slaughtering of millions of their own people since the exile of the Nationalist Party to Taiwan. Like I said, to hell with the so-called ''People's'' Republic of China's government.
 
I think personally it was wrong of him to take a samurai sword to the incident. However, having said that, I think taking the Samurai sword to the incident was "made" justified considering the fact the other men produced knives. The men started the incident on the bus now they cry about one of them being killed. Well don't fucking throw stones in glass houses morons!
 
zombieslayer76 said:
Atleast in America they give you a chance to prove that you or a loved one was in danger, in China your summarily executed and soon afterwards a billboard with your name underlined in red is displayed as an example to the rest of the cattle. And I don't give 2 shits about whether it won't change the mindset of some people, that doesn't justify the slaughtering of millions of their own people since the exile of the Nationalist Party to Taiwan. Like I said, to hell with the so-called ''People's'' Republic of China's government.
And so? In America (if I'm not wrong about it, you can also misjudgea person and send him to prison/trial?
And after that, finding out he's innocent? Let me explain something to you here: unlike in the US/UK, here in Canada (in China and in France), the person is innocent until proven guilty and if proven
guilty, that person is shown to the crowd as a bad example (but only after he's been proven guilty and out of all doubts unlike in the US/England, first thing you do in America/England is to judge a
person as guilty or see him/her as such and after that ask him/her for proof of his/her innocence), contrary to what you Westerners may believe about the Chinese criminal laws regarding an innocent person.

Now having said that, how is any of
what you're saying true about USA?

And if the American government indeed
does let the innocent speak, then things should be run like in the French/Canadian's judicial system (not saying it's perfect at all, but slighter better than the American system on this) not like in England/USA where people could be falsely accused of doing something they didn't do and thrown into prison for it (not saying it can't happen in France or China, but takes place lots more in the US and countries under the British common laws, which is guilty until proven innocent)? Because that's just not fair to the person who's really innocent and not guilty and blaming everything on a person who didn't do anything wrong.
And things like these (slaugthering and emprisonment of their own people) can happen, doesn't matter the country,
and doesn't make it right, no matter
in which country it does take place.

And so your hate of the PRC and China's political regime isn't justified in this case. Because America (as a "democratic-capitalist country) can also do the same thing (here, I'm referring to the slaughter of French/Blacks/Native Americans) to their own people.

And also Germany did the same things during the Holocaust to the Jews (pointed their fingers at them and said they were the guilty ones). America singled out
communist countries and hunting everyone who was "doubted" communist and Americans did the same to the French in Lousiana/Acadia, Blacks, and Native Americans in their history.

So it really just depends on how cruel and heartless the people in power are.
 
Yes, his action was justified.
 
Back
Top