Should DLC be free?

Poll Poll Should All DLC be free?

  • Yes, DLC should be free

    Votes: 5 26.3%
  • No, DLC shouldn't be free

    Votes: 6 31.6%
  • It depends if theres An extensive ammount of content or not in the DLC

    Votes: 8 42.1%

  • Total voters
    19

Midna

The Twilight Princess
Credits
3,903
Heres the argument: you pay for a game and to get more content, you may have to pay. If you had to pay for a game, should you have to pay for more content?
 
The other argument is how much content in the dlc. like if they made 2 new worlds in nsmb2, would it be fair for alot of new content for free?
 
I think DLC should be free, because you already have the game, and why should you pay more for extra content?
 
I don't think DLC should be free.Some develpoers work hard on DLC, so I'm willing to dish out a couple extra bucks for it. On-disc dlc on the other hand, seems stupid.
 
Well, well for the majority of DLC I'd say yes, you should pay a couple of extra bucks for these peoples extra work. However I've come a crossed some DLC that honestly seems rather pointless and should have been in the game in the first place, to put that a different way, sometimes getting DLC, is kinda like getting a 3DS then having to buy a charger separately imo, but that's only sometimes, usually I think you should pay for it.
 
I personally believe that they measure the value of the content on the game they are selling you initially.

Not paying for DLC is basically just not compensating someone for further creativity and innovation. However, I do feel that most DLC is outrageously overpriced, but I suppose that's not for me to decide.
 
Free? No. Cheaper? Yes. We shouldn't spend $3.99 on three different DLC's which are actually just extras for a game. Games are expensive as it is. Honestly, the content should be available in the game to begin with. I understand that it is neat to get extra features to a game though if you really enjoyed it. I would say that no more than $0.99 would be reasonable. It would also be neat if they had deal, such as with Mario, instead of paying full price for all three you could get all three for a discounted price.
 
Depends on the magnitude of the content.

For any sort of "expansion", I'd say no.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Depends on the magnitude of the content.

For any sort of "expansion", I'd say no.

I agree. Expansions? No, they should be updates. Actual DLC content, such as new characters or side-quests with great rewards? Sure.

But something like the Mario Kart 7 patch? No, that should be free (and was). The recent Minecraft patch for the 360? That should be free too (and also was).

But DLC can be over-priced, which is unfortunate. It's quite expensive buying a few costumes for Little Big Planet or some other game, then discovering you could've bought a whole game instead for just an extra dollar or so.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
DLC should not be free.

Why?
DLC is extra content created by the developer and as such is a new product. When you go to the IKEA to buy a bed. You buy what you see. A bed. If then two weeks later a matching cabinet comes out, you have to buy that too if you want it. It is as simple as that.

However:
Some DLC is already on-disc. DLC to me means content the developer spent time on AFTER the release of the game. You actually have to download it. You donnot own it yet. DLC on disc is just silly and should not be necessary. Some DLC should have been there all along. But it's 2012, you are a wel informed consumer. You can google a product and see what is says about it. If it is a bad game or if it has something flawed (for example the mass effect 3 ending). Then don't buy it. Later on there will (for most products anyway) be most likely a complete package for such games. Take for example forza motorsport 3. I did not buy it in the beginning. I did not buy the DLC, I bought the complete edition with all DLC for 30 bucks a year later. Why? Because I am not willing to pay more.

Fair pricing?
No such thing. As long as you are willing to pay that much, it's woth it. If you stop buying DLC in big numbers however. That shows it's to expensive or just not worth it and it would force developers to think about it in a new way.

You think it's unfair?
Well don't buy the product on it's first day. Don't throw money at something you donnot know everything about. And if you wish to support the developer from day 1 and you feel ripped of? addres the company. If they have any respect for there consumerbase they will sent back at least a reply in wich they want to confort you.

smile.gif
 
Most DLC should definitely be payed for. However, I don't appreciate paying the full normal price for a game, and then discovering it's only 'half finished' and you have to have to pay for DLC to get the whole thing. That's wrong. But as for fun things like extra costumes in Little Big Planet or extra playable characters in other games? If it was released much later then the game itself and reasonably priced, that'd be alright. But I'd still much rather see that stuff as 'unlockables' rather then payed for tidbits.
 
There's not much point to it if it's free, may as well have just included it in the game in the first place.

Some of it is included, we just have to pay more to unlock it
wink.gif



Anyway, if DLC adds a lot of content, like extra levels etc. sure its worth paying for. BUT if its something already on the disc or just a different color costume then no it should be free.
 
Back
Top