Should Self Defense Classes be Mandatory?

Demon_Skeith

Administrator
Staff member
Administrator
Top Monthly Contributor
Credits
199,318
Steal Penalty
You're Rich Money Bags Award
Profile Music
I think if it's one thing we can agree on, this world of ours isn't getting any safer. So in a dangerous society, do you think kids weather it happens at schools or outside of them should take self defense classes like judo or karate for a year or two?
 
LET US TOTE GUNS AN WE'LL BE SAFE. lol In seriousness, it should be a high school class so we at least have the option.
 
Couldn't this make it worse since if angry kids get mad at the someone now the teacher and other weaker students might get Karate chopped by a stronger misbehaving student or multiple misbehaving students?

Plus, stronger kids might use their new fighting skills to beat up random people to rob them after school.

Criminals might start carrying dangerous weapons like electric tasers, knives, guns, and swords to protect themselves from Karate students, and cause more innocent people to be hurt with weapons. Karate is not always the best way to defend yourself when someone has a gun or long sword.

Plus, in a few years, almost everyone including the criminals will know Karate because they learned it in school, so self-defense with Karate might not work as well if the criminal been training harder, and is stronger and faster then the innocent people.
 
Couldn't this make it worse since if angry kids get mad at the someone now the teacher and other weaker students might get Karate chopped by a stronger misbehaving student or multiple misbehaving students?

Plus, stronger kids might use their new fighting skills to beat up random people to rob them after school.

Criminals might start carrying dangerous weapons like electric tasers, knives, guns, and swords to protect themselves from Karate students, and cause more innocent people to be hurt with weapons. Karate is not always the best way to defend yourself when someone has a gun or long sword.

Plus, in a few years, almost everyone including the criminals will know Karate because they learned it in school, so self-defense with Karate might not work as well if the criminal been training harder, and is stronger and faster then the innocent people.

well, self-defense meant to be self-defense, not attack. Well, I agree some kids might get too violent and too blood-thirsty. And might rob others of their lunches and steal their precious items, I go along with ya.
 
Couldn't this make it worse since if angry kids get mad at the someone now the teacher and other weaker students might get Karate chopped by a stronger misbehaving student or multiple misbehaving students?

Plus, stronger kids might use their new fighting skills to beat up random people to rob them after school.

Criminals might start carrying dangerous weapons like electric tasers, knives, guns, and swords to protect themselves from Karate students, and cause more innocent people to be hurt with weapons. Karate is not always the best way to defend yourself when someone has a gun or long sword.

Plus, in a few years, almost everyone including the criminals will know Karate because they learned it in school, so self-defense with Karate might not work as well if the criminal been training harder, and is stronger and faster then the innocent people.

which do you think is worse? Facing someone with a gun or facing someone with a knife? Besides, karate teaches discipline which might lead to fewer criminal activity.
 
which do you think is worse? Facing someone with a gun or facing someone with a knife? Besides, karate teaches discipline which might lead to fewer criminal activity.

Both a knife, and a gun can be deadly.

The Army also teaches people discipline, and many other skills to turn young people into strong warriors who can defend their country from invasions, and dangerous groups like terrorists, and revolutionist.

Maybe kids should train in boot camp to get them ready to join the military if they choose to join the military someday.

This can have many benefits like physical fitness, job training to be a soldier, so less unemployment in a country, enough recruits to fight the future wars, teamwork, and discipline.
 
I don't think that self-defence classes should be mandatory. I think that it would just give people that would do something stupid yet another way to do it.

And DS, a stab wound can be just as bad, if not worse than, a bullet wound. Depending on where it is. Slash wounds, for the most part are shallow compaired to the other two. If you'd want to severely wound something. Stab it with a knife.
 
I don't think that self-defence classes should be mandatory. I think that it would just give people that would do something stupid yet another way to do it.

And DS, a stab wound can be just as bad, if not worse than, a bullet wound. Depending on where it is. Slash wounds, for the most part are shallow compaired to the other two. If you'd want to severely wound something. Stab it with a knife.
that's true, never thought of that before, thanks for pointing it out. Well, I mean, just in case you're in the middle of the street, and getting a stab/slash wound and there's nobody around to help you, then you're gonna bleed to death and eventually die from it.
 
that's true, never thought of that before, thatnks for pointing it out. Well, I mean, just in case you're in the middle of the street, and getting a stab/slash wound and there's nobody around to help you, then you're gonna bleed to death and eventually die from it.
Bullet wounds pretty much work one of two ways. You get shot and pass out from shock, or you freak out and a lot of adrenaline goes into you. I've seen people get shot and not know it for quite awhile. Just not knowing where the blood came from.
 
I agree, it would be easier to defend yourself against a knife unless the guy knows how to accurately throw knives, or Ninja Stars like Ninjas/Naruto from far away.

I saw a guy who made a armor suit which can protect him from a bear attack, and a car hitting him. Although, not practical or fashionable, I think inventing armor and a strong suit will protect people who can afford a strong suit, and not be embarrassed to wear a strange looking suit when going outside.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-jYwQacBdGw

Maybe we should learn how to make robotic suits like in Gundam Wing to stay safe with a robotic suit of armor minus the weapons like guns and swords, and flying parts.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=57LH6uSS8pQ
 
Throwing stars aren't made to kill. They're made to wound before a fight. A point-blank gun is less frieghtening to me because I know that I just need to break to the side. A knife can still cut you.
 
There are also Balistic Knives which uses a spring to shoot a knife at you from a few feet away. If a person has 1 or more balistic knives, they can cause a lot of harm from far a way, but I believe it is illegal to own a balistic knive, but I think criminals won't care that it is illegal.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OrlzBj2lIJg

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=locOBI-EG0w
 
I've also heard that ballistic knives aren't the greatest by any means. If you need something that's going to shoot a projectile, get a gun. End of point. And, as I've said DS, throwing a knife isn't going to be much more than a wound, unless it hits you in a few specific spots. Combine this with the fact that throwing a knife 100% accurate is near, if not completely impossible. Personally, I'd rather deal with a pistol, as we're talking about in this conversation than a knife. If it were an automatic rifle, or a shotgun, I'd rather deal with the knife. While a bolt-action rifle wouldn't be too much of an issues either. Either way, both choices are lethal if used properly. Even if it's more likely to be instantly killed by a bullet than a knife. It'd still be more reassuring for me to see someone pull out a glock than a KABAR in a fight. Because most people either won't actually pull the trigger, or they've never used it before and won't expect the recoil. Just remember kids. My argument is from someone who knows what they're doing, and I'd still rather not be in either of these situations, don't get into them yourself, as weapons as a whole are made to kill.
 
Maybe the government should make metal bullets illegal to sell and own, and only allow citizens to own rubber bullets like the type the SWAT and RIOT police use to shoot at rioters, and violent protesters to paralyze/shock them instead of killing them.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h9Gt16FIDjs
 
Back
Top