Should Self Defense Classes be Mandatory?

Fencing, you say?
 
Same for me, but I got a feeling most "public" schools can't afford fencing since those swords, masks, pants, and suits look kind of expensive. Plus, the school don't want to risk someone losing an eye, or another body part by someone fooling around without a mask on.
 
Yep, my best friend took fencing for 3 years in high school, for senior year she took the required health class, and I believe CPR or first aid.

I took weight training, health and nutrition.. I can't remember what I benched, but I know that I was pushing 800 lbs with my legs.

And I went to a public high school, it all depends on the district you are zoned for. Some districts have more money than others, and some have a lot more money than others. When the district does well, they get more money for books and supplies and when a district maintains that success, then there is extra money that goes into recreational activities. Some schools can afford updated books and new supplies if they do well, and the ones that do very well get new books and supplies and new activities and equipment for those activities.The ones that don't do so well, don't get any extra funding, let alone for much needed new books and supplies, programs get cut, and eventually the school gets shut down because of poor performance.

My high school was able to afford books, supplies, fencing swords, gym equipment everything for their electives and clubs even down to the uniforms and assault rifles (even though they used blanks) used in JROTC. Our senior trips were to foreign countries. My best friend (who was a year older) took a tour through Europe with her senior class for the Senior trip. My senior class went on a Caribbean cruise. So it isn't about it being a public school.

My husband and I both went to junior high and elementary school in Brooklyn, and in different districts. The differences between the schools we went to were like night and day. My schools were clean and had great teachers who actually cared enough about the students to bust their asses when they were slipping, and the students respected them, and learned because of it. His school had teachers who were at their wits end, and were getting heat from disrespectful students, equally disrespectful parents and a school board that didn't give a damn other than to cover their ass and no one learned anything because they just didn't care. He was mostly self-taught for all if not most of his school life and got very high grades as a result.

High school was the same even though I went to high school in Queens, while he went in Brooklyn, and in his school, you were good if you weren't apart of a gang, incarcerated, pregnant, didn't have kids or a criminal record. While my text books referenced Bill Clinton as the president, his referenced Jimmy Carter.
 
I learned wrestling in Gym class, and disliked it since touching guys while wrestling is awkward. It wasn't even the type of professional wrestling on TV with a ring, and elastic straps on the side where you can jump on the corner of the ring and fly through the air to slam into opponents. We were not allow to throw our opponents, body slam them, or tackle them very hard like football players.

Wrestling got cancelled after a bigger boy use one hand to pick up a smaller boy by his neck, and slammed him on the mat breaking his arm.
 
We had a fencing club in school for a while but it was cancelled after the teacher had some complications in his health and after that there was not enough interest to restart it. I don't think self defence should be a mandatory subject personally as I can see the options it opens up for bullying both within and outside the class. I feel if people want to learn it by themselves that is fine but a lot of self defence disciplines take a while before you actually learn the defence. This means that most of the time would be spent learning the stances and poses more than anything. This would in turn lead to a lot of bored pupils, particularly those who weren't that interested to begin with and would require lot of time allocated to it, time that the school system really doesn't have to offer.

Also consider that most schools, in Scotland at least, have a massive anti-bullying stance and encourage discussion over action so it would kind of send a mixed message when they encourage you to report instances of bullying to them and let them help you with it while teaching you how to physically counter someone who intimidates you. Even though it could be practical I can appreciate why they would still take the words over actions stance, mostly fears of legal implications if the self defence went too far...

Personally I think if you want to learn it, just go to a class.
 
Should it be mandatory no, but I do think parents should take their kids to a self defense course. In todays world it couldn't hurt and it would help with bullying problems aswell. I am not saying a kid who has a bully should go beat him up after learning Martial Arts,but if the time came where he got in a fight he would stand a chance and could even win.
 
It is better to learn some self defense tricks to protect ourselves.
Nowadays we can never know fully, about anyone and it's better to be safe than sorry.
 
Back
Top