Should the suicidal be saved

Demon_Skeith

Administrator
Staff member
Administrator
Top Monthly Contributor
Credits
199,318
Steal Penalty
You're Rich Money Bags Award
Profile Music
I've been reading some stories of late of those who been trying to kill themselves (house fire, jumping off a high place, ect.) and were rescued.

Do you think they should be rescued? I do not think so, If one wishes to end their life, I say let them so long as it don't affect others. Like going on a gun rampage in a mall or theater.
 
But any suicide affects others.  Think of their family and friends, colleges, etc.  Suicidal people are usually suffering from some sort of mental illness and there are always treatment options...
 
Yes, because they can always look back on this dark time when they persevere through it, and they will be stronger because of it.. but at the same time, you can only do so much.

It should be noted that there is a huge difference between being suicidal, and "being suicidal." That latter is more or less a manipulation tactic used by those who are extremely controlling, obsessive and so fucked in the head, that they would likely take you out if you tried to stop them and then committed suicide afterward.
 
I suppose so but the problem is the majority of people who attempt suicide are teens or are acting without a cool off period.

A person who wants to end their life because their girlfriend dumped them, but a week later they are ok with it.
 
Someone being saved from committing suicide doesn't necessarily mean more hell for them. Each situation would have to be judged on it's own merits, but I am sure there are people in the world that have been saved from suicide and never regretted it since.
 
Demon_Skeith said:
for argument's sake, it's the suicidal who have lost everything (beyond the years of a teenager) and being saved only means more hell for them.
That depends on the reason for the suicide. If it is because of a terminal illness and the states' health officials value the patient's life (read: money) to allow them to end their suffering under medical supervision, then suicide or assisted suicide is the only way out.

You can come back from anything else, and doing so will make you stronger.
 
I thought about this more.

I think people who are found to be attempting suicide should be stopped. Being caught in attempting suicide shows that a person was more interested in getting attention for help considering how easy it is to off yourself.

For myself, I've thought about suicide. More lately than in the past actually so when I saw this topic I was just shocked. For myself suicide was never depression. When I was younger I just simply didn't see a bright future possible. I weighed in the chance of that against the amount of burden to get some peace and balance in my life. It was a well calculated plan. Only one thing stopped me which was the fear of suffering though my death. I was afraid that if I jump off of a building and splat on the ground my body would not function but no one knows if the brain takes minutes to completely shut down. Afraid of stupid things like that.

Just last week I came up to the conclusion that it's impossible for me to commit suicide because I cannot put that negative thing on my son who is only 2yrs old now. I'm not afraid of dying, I could name 5 ways that would be fine and do me over in a minute or two. I don't really have much hope in the future and I wish I could just refuse to take the responsibility for my troubles. Anyway, that option is out of the window for the rest of my life.

Anyway, It's real annoying to just dream of a runaway bus driving into my livingroom and smacks me right in the teeth. If I were to try to commit suicide and others tried to stop me I'd be happy that they are because to get caught doing that just shows there is some hope.
 
It is a personal choice of course.  I don't think it should be "illegal", but unless in the case of terminal illness, things don't stay bad for so long that you have no other option but to kill yourself.  I've dealt with depression for a very very long time, but something inside my soul told me to hang on because things might just get better, and they eventually did....
 
AidsorHIV said:
I suppose so but the problem is the majority of people who attempt suicide are teens or are acting without a cool off period.

A person who wants to end their life because their girlfriend dumped them, but a week later they are ok with it.
Yeah, it's a common problem, they don't realize that there are lot of fish in the sea.
 
FTON said:
Yeah, it's a common problem, they don't realize that there are lot of fish in the sea.
Yes but clearly there other issues if someone wants to end themselves cause of a lost g/f...
 
Back
Top