Trolling Will Soon Be Illegal

Demon_Skeith

Administrator
Staff member
Administrator
Top Monthly Contributor
Credits
199,359
Steal Penalty
You're Rich Money Bags Award
Profile Music
One of the Internet's basic tenets—the right to be as much of a myopic, infantile asshat as humanly possible—is currently under attack in Arizona. A sweeping update to the state's telecommunications harrasment bill could make naughty, angry words a Class 1 misdemeanor. Or worse.

It's a dangerous precedent, yet another bill written and supported by legislators who fundamentally don't understand the nature of the internet. And I'm not just being a, well, you know.

Arizona House Bill 2549 passed both legislative houses last Thursday and is now awaiting approval from Arizona's governor Brewer. The statute states that:

"It is unlawful for any person, with intent to terrify, intimidate, threaten, harass, annoy or offend, to use a ANY ELECTRONIC OR DIGITAL DEVICE and use any obscene, lewd or profane language or suggest any lewd or lascivious act, or threaten to inflict physical harm to the person or property of any person."

Emphasis added. If the electronic devices and means are employed to stalk a victim, the penalty bumps up to a Class 3 felony.
For those not intimately familiar with Arizona penal law, a Class 1 misdemeanor is punishable by a $2,500 fine and up to six months in jail (it's the most aggressive misdemeanor charge the state can bring). A Class 3 felony, meanwhile, carries a minimum sentence of 2.5 years for non-dangerous offenders with no prior record. And a max of 25 years in jail.

Opponents of the bill argue that the wording is overly broad and could easily be interpreted to include not just one-on-one communications but public forums like 4Chan, Reddit, and anywhere else that allows commenting. You thought the banhammer was bad? Try handcuffs.

It could also have a chilling effect on free speech by prohibiting shocking or "profane" language online. And since the bill stipulates that the offense only has to occur on Arizona soil (since a Facebook comment is definitely a geographic place, right?) that basically puts the entire Internet on notice.

The bill's supporters argue that the steps are necessary to prevent online bullying. Despite the public outcry, the bill has seen very little resistance from elected officials. However, given how well Arizona's other recent, short-lived, and generally draconian propositions—-including its racial profiling, anti-gay adoption, and anti-immigration bills—-have fared, House Bill 2549 might not be a law for long, assuming Governor Brewer even signs it.

source

good luck enforcing it.
 
Hopefully this means that some get punished, and might convince some that trolling is not a worth while activity.
 
There should be punishment for people who make violent threats against others or their property online since you never know if they are serious about harming others, but 25 years is too long for most trolling. Paying a ticket/fine or community service would be a better punishment.

There have been people who died from online trolling also called cyber bullying in the news, so they should be more punishment if someone died because of cyberbullying.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VUd0v7z5KO0
 
Those who died from online cyber bulling or trolling should never have been on in the first place if there that weak minded.


But I agree there should be harsh laws in place to protect people.
 
I'm guessing most who have died from cyberbullying also experience real physical bullying like the kid in the story. The internet and cell phones are just another way for bullies to contact their victim without the victim's parent finding out since many parents aren't very involve in their children online life.
 
Trolling should be a punishable offense. If trolls conducted themselves the same way offline towards people that they do online, then they would be arrested or fined for harrassment.

Bypassing a ban online to continue the harrassment is like continuing to harrass or stalk a person offline even after they've asked you to leave them alone, you've been warned by the police and that person had gone to the police for a restraining order.

If behaving in this manner is already illegal offline, then it stands to reason that behaving this way should be illegal online.

Identity theft is just as illegal online as it is offline, and the same should be the case for harrassment.

And the suicides from being bullied online occur because the bullying had escalated from the internet to the victim's front door.

It is only a matter of time before some kid who is a victim of cyber bullying to be bullied offline, and vice versa.

There is no separation of the two anymore, and there hasn't been for a long time, because anybody can share a link.

The fact that it is online means that it could be anyone, anywhere at any given time doing the harrassment, and trolling could be the very beginning of cyberbullying.
 
Personally, a few comments aren't an issue really and it'd be pointless to chase after all of them, so they're best left to the individual site admins. The real issue is when it goes from like 1 to like 1000. Or it's gone from a one off situation to repeatedly. That's when I'd like to see some intervention. Though I'd class it under harassment or the cyber bullying rather than create a new law entirely for trolling only (since once it goes from 1 to 1000 messages then I'd call it actual harassment rather than trolling). Something like:
"Whosoever takes measures to circumvent tools to prevent users from accessing sites and uses an electronic device to terrify, abuse, intimidate or threaten any other person shall be subject to punishments of fines not exceeding 2,500$ or 60 hours of community service."
This way if they don't try to hide then admins can deal with it easily on their own. But if it's the same person again and again... Then they can report it to cyber crimes and have an investigator intervene for a more permanent real life solution.

Though the core issue I see with this law is enforcement. It might work on facebook or twitter if someone has their real life details posted with geotagging enabled (and even then, how would it work if the one making the comments doesn't reside in Arizona, or even America). But on all others? Good luck proving anything if they use fake names/details and proxies. And that is the major issue... enact all the laws you want, it won't matter if they're impossible to enforce or no one ever gets caught for them. No one will respect/fear/honour a law if they feel that they can get away with doing otherwise.

Though I agree, there are many cases now where online actions are directly affecting offline situations and something needs to be done to prevent it. There was a case of a college student who commited suicide because his roommate videotaped him having sex with his boyfriend (he was in the closet) and posted/streamed the feed online without the one being taped's consent. Multiple legal issues there.
Cyber bullying is a major issue, before it was bad... But at least at the end of the day you could go home and it'd end. Now that's not true anymore. They can keep it up all the time on facebook or twitter or their blogs. They can also make it so everyone can see and join in on it. We're talking about a global audience of not just the 100 in that grade or the 1000 who might attend that school, but the entire facebook/twitter/internet population.

Demon, it's also not merely as simple as someone being weak willed. Imagine that for the next 3-5 years (or more... Like if it begins in grade 7 and goes right up until grade 12) you are going to be the butt of every joke, every insult under the sun will be made about you, they're going to laugh all day. Now that's just at school... When you go home, your online world is going to be filled with even more public messages, personal messages, posts on your wall, people posting photoshopped images they took of you during the day, etc... telling you how worthless or pathetic you are. And the fun part? It will never go away. All those comments uploaded to the internet are there to stay, you cannot ever remove them permanently. Even if you did get some removed, more would be posted and there wouldn't be anything you could do to stop them. For more fun, imagine that you have no friends thanks to all these lies and comments being posted/made. No one wants to be around you for fear they're going to be targeted too. Can you imagine how utterly devastating that would be?

So like I mentioned, it's not about being weak willed... rather it's about them weakening your resistance down for a long time until you can't take any more. And eventually you crack. Everyone cracks, it's not a question of if, it's only a question of when. And unfortunately there only seem to be 3 outcomes of extreme bullying, and in all cases it involves a death. (Either the victim via suicide, the bully by murder, or sometimes... both.)
 
I just wanted to say that just because someone can't fight back or handle the stress of being bullied on a daily basis, doesn't make them weak minded or weak willed. Not everyone can put their childhood bully in the emergency room with injuries severe enough to scare his family back to their place of origin like I did.

Things were a lot different when I grew up compared to the way they are now, and nowadays, the bullying can last well into adulthood. If I had beat someone to near death today like I did when I was younger, then it is pretty safe to say that I would have been dead.

Todays kids like to have guns and gangs and so even if you fought your bully fair and square and won, that doesn't mean that the fight is over, it means that you are marked for death. Sometimes, the smartest move is to not fight back, but that is not to say that the victim can handle the online and offline bullying at the same time as well.

To make matters worse, it is not just kids that are being bullied it is adults as well.. and also, the bullying doesn't stop after the victim is dead.. because the surviving, grieving family are bullied as well. No one is safe nowadays, and there are some adults who bully children, such as Jennifer Petkov, a 33 year old woman who not only tormented her sick neighbor, Laura Edwards, but when she died, Petkov also bullied her sick daughter Kathleen, and she died earlier this year. She was 9 years old.

Jennifer Petkov first made national news after she posted photos of Laura and Kathleen on Facebook. The doctored images were of Laura being embraced by the grim reaper and Kathleen in a skull and cross bones.

http://www.cbsnews.com/8301-504763_162-20019377-10391704.html

There were many who were and still are outraged by this, but there are also those who say that Petkov did nothing wrong and that her actions were a harmless joke.
 
Back
Top