Animal Crossing hands down. AC can be played for years (literally) and DK would be mere hours. Plus AC has online co-op and DK is just a story-line driven game and I don't think it even has co-op.
I have the same dilemma as the OP - right now I'm leaning towards Donkey Kong as I love a good, challenging platformer. Animal Crossing is great for multiplayer and socialization features and should be a no-brainer except for that I find it a 'high-maintenance' game. To experience everything and get all the stuff you want demands that you play the game everyday at different hours (or constantly change your system time). Ignore the game for a period of time and find your town overrun with weeds and residents moving out. I have 943242313423 other games in my backlog across consoles and can't devote a lot of time, every day, to play a single game. When I played AC:Wild World on the DS, I felt like a slave to the game at times. Regardless, it was a fun game and I didn't regret my purchase.
I have the same dilemma as the OP - right now I'm leaning towards Donkey Kong as I love a good, challenging platformer. Animal Crossing is great for multiplayer and socialization features and should be a no-brainer except for that I find it a 'high-maintenance' game. To experience everything and get all the stuff you want demands that you play the game everyday at different hours (or constantly change your system time). Ignore the game for a period of time and find your town overrun with weeds and residents moving out. I have 943242313423 other games in my backlog across consoles and can't devote a lot of time, every day, to play a single game. When I played AC:Wild World on the DS, I felt like a slave to the game at times. Regardless, it was a fun game and I didn't regret my purchase.
I put my Wild World down for months or even years at a time. It takes about 15 minutes to pick all of the weeds and you have about 3 days after returning to rebuild friendships before the residents leave. I don't change my date or feel slave to the game. I typically just make sure I pick it up on real life holidays to experience the events and when a season changes in real life, I catch all the fish in that season, catch the bugs, and ship em off to the museum. Doing that right away I only have the fossils to worry about collecting - which keeps me having something to do whenever I pop into my town for fun at my own leisure.
What type of game are you after? Because Donkey Kong Country Returns 3D and Animal Crossing New Leaf are in no way comparable to one another.
If you want a game based more around reflexes and 'skill' and which is geared towards single player, pick Donkey Kong Country Returns 3D.
If you want a game with theoretically endless replay value that's more of a simulation with multiplayer features (but no story/adventure elements), pick Animal Crossing.
Well they both look really fun. I love Donkey Kong I play him alot off my sister's DS but Animal Crossing looks really cool and exciting too but I just don't know what to choose
yeah, this reminds me to take all animal crossing games off of my wish lists. another The Sims or MY Sims is all i need. ffs. i use to own My Sims and Kingdom, and i use to love those games, but man i changed..